Choosing Between Insurance and Private Pay for Your Private Practice: What You Need to Know
When starting a private practice, one of the most frequently asked questions is whether to accept insurance or operate on a private pay basis. This is a crucial decision with many factors to consider, and it’s perfectly okay to make adjustments as you go along. Remember, you don’t have to get everything perfect from the start. Sometimes, you might need to change your approach as the needs of your practice and clients evolve. Here are some key considerations to help guide your decision:
1. Prioritize What Works for You
The most important factor is to choose a payment model that suits your needs and preferences. Many practice owners choose their payment model based on client demands, but this can lead to burnout and dissatisfaction. While serving your clients is important, your practice should be designed to support your well-being and professional satisfaction. Opt for a model that aligns with your values and business goals to avoid feeling overwhelmed and unhappy in your work.
2. Reflect on Your Practice's Culture
Consider the values and vision you have for your practice. Your payment model should reflect how you want to operate your business and the principles that matter to you. For instance, if you’re passionate about working with specific groups, such as teachers, it might be beneficial to accept the insurance they use. On the other hand, if you prefer not to be constrained by insurance companies’ diagnostic codes and treatment guidelines, a private pay model might be more appropriate.
3. Evaluate Your Marketing Efforts
The amount of marketing you’ll need to do can vary significantly depending on your payment model. Insurance-based practices often have clients referred to them through insurance companies, which can reduce the need for extensive marketing. Conversely, private pay practices require more proactive marketing to attract clients. It’s a common misconception that private pay practices cannot build a full caseload. With dedication and effective marketing, it is certainly possible. For example, I run a group practice with over 15 therapists that operates on a cash-pay basis. While it requires effort, it is achievable.
4. Consider Your Caseload and Income
Insurance-based practices typically need to negotiate rates with insurance companies. These rates can vary, with some insurance companies offering favorable rates and others less so. As a result, insurance-based practices often need to see more clients to achieve the same income as a private pay practice, which may see fewer clients but charge higher fees. Think about how each model will affect your income and caseload.
5. Take Your Community Into Account
Building a private pay practice can be more challenging in rural areas. In such communities, you might need to consider accepting insurance to attract clients or adjust your rates to remain competitive. If you choose to accept insurance, research which plans are most commonly used in your area and consider joining those networks.
Next Steps
Given the unique challenges you may face, I've developed various resources to support your journey. From a weekly podcast and a vibrant Facebook community to a comprehensive Wise Practice Membership Community and engaging in-person events, I'm committed to providing the guidance and tools you need for a thriving Christian private practice.
In conclusion:
Ultimately, the best choice for your practice is the one that aligns with your personal and professional goals. Nothing is set in stone, and it’s common for practices to shift their payment models over time. You might start with one model and gradually transition to another, or add insurance panels to a primarily private pay practice. There is no definitive right or wrong answer—only what works best for you and your unique situation.
Remember, flexibility and adaptation are key. Choose a model that supports your vision and goals, and adjust as needed to ensure your practice remains fulfilling and sustainable.
Are you currently starting a practice and considering locations? Do you have a community that you can count on in your journey as a practice owner? We need others for guidance and support. We need friends who understand what we are going through. That’s part of the reason why I love the Wise Practice Community (a group of faith-based counseling practice owners) so much. The Community is meeting this October for the Wise Practice Summit in Charlotte, NC.
Other Ways to Build a Community Before and After You Grow Your Faith-Based Practice: Let’s Talk About Summits
Joining summits presents a multitude of advantages for individuals seeking personal and professional growth. Summits bring together industry experts, thought leaders, and like-minded individuals, creating a unique platform for networking, knowledge sharing, and inspiration. Attending a summit offers the opportunity to connect with professionals from diverse backgrounds, expanding your network and opening doors to potential collaborations and partnerships. The wealth of knowledge shared by renowned speakers and panelists can expose you to new ideas, trends, and perspectives, helping you stay ahead in your field. Summits often feature workshops, seminars, and interactive sessions, providing valuable learning experiences and practical skills development. Moreover, the energy and motivation derived from being surrounded by passionate individuals can inspire personal growth, ignite creativity, and fuel aspirations. Overall, joining summits is an investment in personal and professional development, empowering individuals to learn, connect, and thrive in their respective fields.
Interested in Making Sure You Are on Track?
Implementing ways to track your calls coming into your practice can support your insight into what is going on and why. It allows you to see if your practice's marketing efforts are reaching clients or if some adjustments need to be made.
At Whitney Owens Consulting, I offer guidance and support when it comes to setting up new tracking methods for your practice. I will also support you in creating an environment where you can grow your practice and know what the data says is going on. Reach out today to get started on the path to a successful practice! Ready to grow?
Apply to consult to discuss your practice and your goals.
Learn more about me and my services.
Grow your practice today!
Implementing new methods into your practice can be overwhelming, especially if you are unsure of what is the best route to take. This is why I offer a range of personalized business coaching services to help you make a plan, execute it and track the results. We offer 3-month and 6-month business consulting packages, Enneagram Training, and a Wise Practice Community Membership. Implement tracking methods for your practice today and reach out to Wise Practice Consulting if you need help getting started! Get in touch today to learn more.
